Compliance intelligence
iClear Compliance Intelligence July 2026
Published
DownloadExecutive summary
Interpretation, not rule-following
While June highlighted the ASA's increasing use of AI to proactively identify non-compliant advertising, July demonstrates that the bigger challenge for marketers is becoming one of interpretation rather than simple rule-following.
Several rulings centered on nuanced application of existing rules, particularly the new Less Healthy Food (LHF) advertising restrictions. The message for marketing teams is clear: understanding the CAP Code is no longer enough - teams increasingly need to understand how the ASA interprets and applies those rules in practice.
This is where regulatory precedent and experience become increasingly valuable. The combination of Clearcast's decades of advertising interpretation and iClear's AI-assisted compliance review provides a practical way to identify issues before campaigns go live.
This month's headlines
23
upheld rulings this month, spanning digital, broadcast and owned channels.
9
LHF announcements - 3 upheld. The new rules continue to evolve through ASA precedent.
61%
of uphelds were digital paid ads or search - still the dominant risk surface.
- Advertising compliance is becoming more nuanced, requiring interpretation rather than simple rule-following.
- The new Less Healthy Food (LHF) rules continue to evolve through ASA precedent. With 9 announcements this month (3 upheld)
- Major brands such as Qatar Airways, EE, and Mars to name just a few received upheld rulings.
- Competitor complaints remain an important route to ASA investigations.
- Long-running investigations reinforce the need for robust audit trails and evidence.
01 - Dashboard
Compliance dashboard
Uphelds by rule breached
Count of upheld rulings · 23 total
- Misleading12
- Substantiation11
- Less Healthy Food & Drink (LHF) Advertising3
- Environmental claims3
Totals exceed 23 - many rulings breached more than one rule.
Uphelds by media type
Where non-compliant ads appeared
- Digital paid ad / search61%
- Own website or email22%
- Broadcast or VOD9%
- Other9%
Top sectors
Share of uphelds · top three
- Home & Garden products22%
- Health & Healthcare17%
- Food & Supplements17%
Notable brands
- Qatar Airways
- EE
- Mars
- Domino's Pizza
02 - Feature article
Compliance is becoming more nuanced
If June demonstrated that the ASA is changing how it identifies non-compliant advertising through AI-powered Active Ad Monitoring, July demonstrates that the rules themselves are becoming harder to apply.
Increasingly, marketers are not dealing with obvious breaches, but with nuanced questions of interpretation. The CAP Code provides the framework, but the outcome often depends on how the ASA believes the average consumer will interpret an advert and how previous rulings have established regulatory precedent.
This is particularly evident in the new LHF regime. Rather than asking simply ‘Is this advert for a less healthy product?’, marketers now have to consider product-level nutritional profiling, whether a campaign promotes an individual product or an entire range, and whether brand assets or creative execution bring an identifiable product into scope.
These are judgment calls rather than checklist items, reinforcing the importance of regulatory expertise alongside technology.
03 - Rule in focus
Less Healthy Food Advertising
Domino's had two separate rulings relating to a total of 5 different creatives and media placements, all investigated versus the Less Healthy Food rules [CAP 15.19].
Domino's Pizza
Not upheld
Domino's Vegi Supreme
A brand can advertise pizza if the specific product is not LHF and cannot reasonably be identified as an LHF product.
Upheld
Domino's Cheeky Little Pizza
A range-level promotion can fall within scope if consumers would associate it with LHF products in that range.
Investigation 1
What happened?
The ASA assessed whether Domino's paid social ads for its pizza promotion were advertising an identifiable less healthy food product. The assessment involved two key tests:
Was the specific product shown a less healthy food product?
The ASA accepted that the pizza shown was the Vegi Supreme classic crust, which did not meet the criteria for a less healthy food product.
If the product was not identified, could consumers reasonably identify it as a specific less healthy product?
The ASA compared the advert's imagery against Domino's wider range and concluded the pizza shown was visually distinguishable from Domino's less healthy products.
As a result, the ASA concluded the ads were brand advertisements rather than advertisements for an identifiable less healthy food product and were therefore outside the scope of the restriction.
Investigation 2
UpheldMedia: Paid Social, TV and Video on Demand
What happened?
The ASA investigated Domino's “Cheeky Little Pizza” advertising after the advertiser used incorrect nutritional information when assessing whether certain pizzas were less healthy. As a result, products featured in the campaign were incorrectly classified and some pizzas shown were considered less healthy food products under the new rules.
A more complex issue arose with one of the ads where the specific pizza shown was not itself classified as less healthy. However, the ASA considered that the advert promoted the wider “Cheeky Little Pizza” range and promotion, which included other products that were less healthy. As consumers would understand the campaign as promoting the range rather than only the specific pizza shown, the advert was considered to be advertising identifiable less healthy products.
Mars
The Mars ruling addressed a different question entirely: when does brand advertising become product advertising?
The Mars campaign featured the iconic M&M characters rather than the physical product itself, which Mars argued was brand advertising and therefore outside the scope of the LHF restrictions. However, after considering the characters' distinctive features, including their colors, shapes and recognizable design elements, the ASA concluded that consumers would associate the creative with identifiable M&M products. As a result, the advert was considered to be advertising a less healthy food product.
04 - Route to investigation
Competitor complaints
Not every investigation begins with a consumer complaint. High-profile disputes between competitors, including Vodafone and Sky over EE advertising, demonstrate that comparative claims remain subject to close scrutiny from rival brands as well as regulators.
- Vodafone
- Sky
Before you publish
Compliance checklist
- Can every factual claim be substantiated?
- Are qualifications sufficiently prominent?
- Does the campaign comply with sector-specific rules?
- Could new LHF rules apply?
- Is the advert clearly recognizable as marketing?
- Would a competitor challenge these claims?
- Would the ASA interpret the advert as intended?
05 - Perspective
Our thoughts
The biggest lesson from July is that compliance is increasingly about interpretation rather than rule memorization. AI can accelerate compliance review, but it is most powerful when combined with regulatory expertise and precedent.
Clearcast has spent more than 60 years interpreting advertising regulation in real-world creative. iClear combines that experience with AI-assisted review to help marketers identify potential issues earlier, reduce costly rework and launch campaigns with greater confidence.
60+
years of Clearcast experience interpreting advertising regulation in real-world creative.
AI
assisted review from iClear, identifying potential issues earlier in the workflow.
Looking ahead
As compliance becomes more nuanced, embedding it into the creative workflow will become increasingly important.
Expect continued scrutiny of digital advertising, further clarification of the LHF rules through ASA precedent and ongoing focus on transparency, substantiation and sector-specific regulation.